Supply Stores (Manhattan):

Blick (will definitely have everything on your list! and cheaper than most…)
1 Bond St # A
New York, NY 10012-2307
(212) 533-2444

Michael’s (warning: they may not have everything on your list, but they are close!)
808 Columbus Ave (btw 97th & 100th), New York

Pearl Paint
308 Canal Street, New York

21 East 13th Street (flagship store)

237 W 23rd Street
Between 7th and 8th Aves. (C or E train to 23rd)

NY Central (Really great paper selection!)
62 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10003

Janoff’s Office and Art Supplies (more expensive, but close if you don’t have much time)
2870 Broadway at 110th